AXIAL-FLUX MACHINES
Brian J. Chalmers
University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology
Manchester, UK
Introduction
While the majority of rotating electrical machines
have radial flux in the air gap between stator and rotor there is
a growing interest in machines which have axial flux in the air gap
between stators and rotors which are essentially disc-shaped. In fact,
for any radial-flux or cylindrical electrical machine there is an
axial-flux or disc-type equivalent. Probably the main reason to consider
an axial-gap topology is its suitability for mechanical system integration.
There are many forms of axial-flux machines; this review is concentrated
upon types which have attracted my attention.
FORMATS OF AXIAL FLUX MACHINES
The possible formats of axial-flux machines are
summarised below. In general, the armature, which carries induced
emfs and load currents, may be either stationary or rotating. Alternative
armature arrangements include:
- Ironless armature - requiring greater magnetising
mmf than an armature with iron core
- Solid armature - in which induced currents circulate
within a solid conducting material, which may or may
not be ferromagnetic
- Slotless armature - having coils wound around
a laminated, or composite, iron core
- Slotted armature - with conductors located in
slots and requiring less magnetising mmf than a slotless armature.
Topologies Include:
- Single-sided machine
- Double-sided machine, with either one central
armature or two outer armatures
- Multiple disc machine
BRUSHED DC MACHINES WITH AXIAL FLUX
Axial-flux brushed dc motors have existed for
many years. Typically, their stationary field system comprises one
or two sets of permanent magnets mounted on disc-shaped steel endplates,
one set of magnets sometimes being replaced by a simple mild steel
flux-return plate. The armature is often ironless. Windings may be
of printed circuit type, or stamped from copper sheet, or may be wire-wound
[1]. Attributes claimed for these motors include fast response, high
efficiency, good commutation and high power-to-weight ratio [2]. [
AN ILLUSTRATION OF A MAVILOR PRODUCT MAY BE INCLUDED HERE]
SOLID ARMATURE MACHINES
The earliest example of an axial-flux machine
with solid armature was the Faraday disc. The rotating copper disc
`armature` required sliding contacts for current collection and the
space utilisation was very poor.
The family of eddy current machines, including couplings, brakes and
dynamometers, have solid `armatures` in which an iron member carries
both flux and induced currents. A high-performance eddy-current dynamometer
with axial flux was developed for use in commercial testing of automotive
engine systems [3]. This is a double-sided homopolar inductor machine
in which a pulsation of unidirectional axial flux is produced by rotation
of a central toothed rotor, causing power to be dissipated as eddy-current
losses in twin outer loss members of pure iron. Note that neither
the `armature` nor the field system rotate. The rotor is a simple
toothed member cut from a steel plate. The symmetrical arrangement,
with a dc excitation coil and a loss member on each side, minimises
magnetic asymmetry and axial forces. Eddy currents flow in the plane
face of each loss member adjacent to the airgap and heat is removed
very effectively by water flowing in circumferential channels in the
faces of the lossplates remote from the air gap. Loadings in these
machines are very high. Thus, peak flux density in the air gap is
about 1.75 T. Electric loading in the loss members is about 160 A/mm
of periphery at the mean radius. Designed loss density at rated power
is 100 W/sq.cm. which is several times that occurring in the largest
turbine generators. The specific power is exceptionally high, at 10
kW/kg. The range of four production machines had ratings of 70 kW
at 12,000 rev/min, 165 kW at 10,000 rev/min, 300 kW at 7,500 rev/min
and 500 kW at 4,500 rev/min. The 500 kW machine required an active
area of about 0.25sq.m. per side, with a rotor diameter of just 0.61
m. These dynamometers have been applied all over the world.
BRUSHLESS MACHINES WITH AXIAL FLUX
As for conventional brushless dc motors, the
corresponding arrangements of brushless axial-flux machines have stationary
armatures and rotating permanent-magnet field systems. A variety of
topologies have been developed and may be used as either motors or
generators. [AN ILLUSTRATION OF A MAVILOR PRODUCT MAY BE INCLUDED
HERE]
The double-sided Torus machine, with a central stator and twin outer
rotors, was developed at UMIST [4]. A simple toroidal strip-wound
steel stator core carries a slotless toroidal winding which may have
any chosen number of phases. For dc generator applications, rectifiers
may conveniently be mounted on the stator casing. Machines of this
type have been developed for a variety of applications [5]. Again,
the symmetrical arrangement minimises mechanical unbalance but special
attention has to be given to control axial magnetic forces of attraction
during assembly of the machine. Analysis has shown that optimal Torus
designs have magnet thickness in the range one to two times the winding
thickness. A more economic solution may be offered by slotted strip-wound
stator cores, which require smaller magnet thickness.
Single-sided motors with slotted stator have been developed for motor-in-wheel
drives for solar powered vehicles [6]. An extra thrust bearing was
provided to support the axial force exerted by the magnets. This successful
design had a high efficiency (c. 94%), as necessary for this application,
and has been used by many constructors in long-distance solar-powered
race vehicles.
Multiple disc construction is applicable when it is desired to produce
high output and rotational forces impose a limit on rotor diameter.
Multiple-disc, high-speed generators have been developed for which
special attention was given to mechanical design [7]. The armatures
are ironless and magnet flux passes axially through the machine from
end to end.
INDUCTION MACHINES WITH AXIAL FLUX
As usual for induction motors, air gap length
must be small and slotting effects must be controlled. Axial-flux
induction motors should therefore use slotted strip-wound cores with
small slot openings. Slot skew, usually in the rotor, is also desirable
and achievable. Single-sided construction necessitates attention to
axial forces. Machines of this type are in production.
References
[1] Campbell,P: "Principles of a permanent-magnet
axial-field dc machine", Proc.IEE, 121, December 1974, pp.1489-1494.
[2] Corbett,A, and Mohamad,MT: "The disc armature dc motor and its
applications", IEE Conf. Pub. No.136, Small Electrical Machines,
1976. pp.59-62.
[3] Chalmers,BJ, and Dukes,BJ: "High-performance eddy-current dynamometers",
IEE Proc., 127, January 1980, pp.20-28.
[4] Spooner,E, and Chalmers,BJ: "TORUS- a slotless toroidal-stator
permanent-magnet generator", IEE Proc,B,139,January 1992, pp.497-506.
[5] Chalmers,BJ, Spooner,E, Honorati,O, Crescimbini,F, and Caricchi,F:
"Compact permanent-magnet machines", Electric Machines and Power
Systems, 25,6,1997, pp.635-648.
[6] Patterson,D, and Spee,R: "The design and development of an axial
flux permanent magnet brushless dc motor for wheel drive in a solar
powered vehicle", IEEE IAS Conf. Rec., Denver, Vol.1,1994,pp.188-195.
[7] Etmad,S: "High speed permanent magnet axial flux generator",
IEE Seminar on Permanent Magnet Materials - Fundamentals, Design
and Application, July 2000.
For
more information vist. www.automotioninc.com
|